Economic vs Non-Economic Damages in Wrongful Death Claims

TL;DR

In a wrongful death claim, economic damages refer to the specific, calculable financial losses resulting from a person’s death. These include lost income, future earning potential, medical bills from the final injury, and funeral expenses. Non-economic damages, on the other hand, compensate for the intangible, human losses that have no exact price tag. This category covers the surviving family’s mental anguish, grief, loss of companionship, and the loss of a parent’s guidance. While economic damages are proven with financial documents and expert analysis, non-economic damages are determined by a jury based on testimony and evidence of the relationship’s quality.

Key Highlights

Economic Damages: These are the tangible financial costs, such as lost wages, medical treatment costs, and loss of benefits like health insurance.
Non-Economic Damages: These are the intangible personal losses, including the family’s sorrow, loss of consortium for a spouse, and loss of parental care for a child.
Calculation Method: Economic damages are calculated using receipts, pay stubs, and expert financial projections. Non-economic damages are subjective and valued by a jury.
Legal Purpose: Both types of damages are intended to provide financial compensation to eligible surviving family members for the full scope of their loss due to another party’s negligence.

When a person’s life is cut short due to the negligence or wrongful act of another, the law provides a path for their surviving family members to seek justice. This legal action is known as a wrongful death claim. In the United States, preventable injuries are a leading cause of death, with data from the National Safety Council indicating tens of thousands of such fatalities each year from events like motor vehicle collisions, medical errors, and workplace incidents. These are not just statistics; they represent families who have suddenly lost a parent, spouse, or child, and with that loss comes significant emotional and financial turmoil.

Wrongful death statutes exist in every state, though the specific rules and procedures can vary significantly. These laws empower designated survivors, typically a spouse, children, or parents, to file a civil lawsuit against the at-fault party. The central purpose of such a lawsuit is to recover damages, which is the legal term for monetary compensation. The law recognizes that no amount of money can replace a human life. However, it also acknowledges that the death creates real, measurable financial burdens and profound personal suffering that deserve recognition and compensation.

The compensation sought in these claims is divided into two fundamental categories: economic damages and non-economic damages. Understanding the distinction between these two types of compensation is crucial for families who are considering legal action. Economic damages address the direct financial impact of the death, while non-economic damages attempt to quantify the deep, personal void left behind. The following sections will provide a clear and detailed examination of each category, explaining what they cover, how they are proven in court, and the legal factors that can influence the final award.

Get the compensation your family deserves, talk to Life Justice Law Group now.

A Detailed Breakdown of Economic Damages in Wrongful Death

Economic damages form the financial foundation of a wrongful death claim. They are designed to compensate the surviving family members for the measurable monetary losses they have suffered and will continue to suffer due to their loved one’s passing. Because these damages are tied to actual numbers and financial data, they are often calculated with the help of forensic economists and other financial experts who can create a clear picture of the economic void left by the decedent.

Lost Income and Earning Capacity

For many families, the most significant economic loss is the decedent’s future income. This component of the claim aims to replace the wages, salaries, and other earnings the deceased would have provided for their family had they lived a full life. Calculating this amount is a complex process that goes far beyond simply multiplying their last salary by their expected remaining years of work.

An expert will consider several factors to project this loss accurately:

Age and Health: The decedent’s age, general health, and life expectancy before the fatal incident.
Profession and Education: Their level of education, skills, and professional trajectory.
Income History: A thorough review of past tax returns, pay stubs, and employment contracts.
Promotion Prospects: The likelihood of future raises, promotions, and bonuses based on their career path and performance.
Inflation and Economic Trends: Adjustments are made to account for inflation and the rising cost of living over time.

For example, the projected lost income for a 35-year-old surgeon with decades of high-earning potential would be substantially different from that of a 62-year-old individual nearing retirement. The final projected amount is then typically reduced to its “present value,” which is the lump sum of money that, if invested today, would grow to cover the family’s future financial needs.

Loss of Services, Support, and Benefits

Beyond a paycheck, a person contributes to their household in countless ways that have a real economic value. This category of damages, often called “loss of services,” compensates the family for the monetary value of the tasks and support the deceased used to provide. An expert may be hired to assign a market value to these contributions.

Examples of lost services include:

Childcare and Tutoring: The cost of hiring a nanny or tutor to replace the care a parent provided.
Home Maintenance: The expense of hiring professionals for tasks like plumbing, car repairs, landscaping, and general handiwork.
Financial Management: The value of managing household budgets, investments, and taxes.
Household Chores: The cost associated with cooking, cleaning, and shopping.

Additionally, this category includes the loss of employment-related benefits. If the deceased had a health insurance plan that covered the family, the family can claim the cost of purchasing a replacement policy. The same applies to lost retirement contributions, pension plans, and other perks that are no longer available.

Medical Expenses Incurred Before Death

If the deceased received medical care for their injuries between the time of the incident and their death, the costs of that care are recoverable as economic damages. This applies whether the person was treated for a few hours in an emergency room or spent weeks in an intensive care unit. These expenses are straightforward to prove with medical bills and records. Common examples include ambulance transportation, hospital stays, surgical procedures, medication, and rehabilitative therapy.

Funeral and Burial Costs

The final component of economic damages is the cost associated with the funeral and burial. The law allows the family to recover all reasonable expenses for a funeral service, cremation or burial, a casket or urn, a burial plot, and a headstone. These costs are easily documented with receipts and invoices from the funeral home and cemetery.

Unpacking Non-Economic Damages: The Intangible Costs of Loss

Non-economic damages address the profound human element of a wrongful death. They are intended to compensate for losses that are not easily measured in dollars but are nonetheless real and devastating. While economic damages restore a family’s financial stability, non-economic damages acknowledge the emotional and relational devastation caused by the loss. Proving these damages relies heavily on the testimony of family and friends who can speak to the depth of the relationships and the impact of the death.

Pain and Suffering of the Deceased (Survival Actions)

In some states, the law allows the decedent’s estate to bring a “survival action” alongside the family’s wrongful death claim. A wrongful death claim compensates the family for their own losses, while a survival action compensates the estate for the suffering the deceased person endured before they died. This claim seeks damages for the conscious pain, terror, and emotional distress the victim experienced from the moment of injury until their death.

For example, if a person was trapped in a vehicle after a crash and was aware of their injuries and impending death, their estate could claim damages for that period of suffering. Conversely, if a person died instantly and without any awareness, a claim for their pain and suffering would likely not be possible. Evidence for a survival action might include witness testimony, medical records, and expert opinions on the victim’s level of consciousness.

Mental Anguish and Emotional Distress of Survivors

This is a core component of the family’s non-economic damages. It compensates the surviving spouse, children, and parents for the immense grief, sorrow, depression, and psychological trauma they experience. The legal system recognizes that the sudden, violent loss of a close family member inflicts a unique and lasting emotional wound. To demonstrate the extent of this anguish, family members may testify about their sleepless nights, anxiety, loss of enjoyment of life, and the need for therapy or counseling.

Loss of Companionship, Consortium, and Society

These legal terms describe the loss of the relationship itself. They acknowledge that a person provides more than financial support; they provide love, affection, comfort, and companionship.

Loss of Consortium: This specifically applies to a surviving spouse and refers to the loss of the marital relationship. It includes the loss of intimacy, affection, moral support, and the ability to have children.
Loss of Society and Companionship: This applies to all close family members, including children and parents. It compensates for the loss of the decedent’s presence in their lives, the shared experiences that will never happen, and the comfort they provided. A jury will consider the quality of the relationship, how much time the family spent together, and the emotional bonds they shared.

Loss of Parental Guidance and Nurture

When a child loses a parent, they lose more than a caregiver; they lose a guide, a teacher, and a moral compass. This specific type of non-economic damage compensates minor children for the loss of their parent’s training, education, advice, and nurturing. It recognizes that a parent’s influence is critical to a child’s development and that its absence is a profound and permanent loss. Testimony about the parent’s involvement in the child’s life, from helping with homework to coaching a sports team, can be powerful evidence to support this claim.

How Are These Damages Calculated and Proven in Court?

The methods for calculating and proving economic and non-economic damages are fundamentally different. One relies on objective data and expert calculations, while the other depends on subjective evidence and the judgment of a jury. A successful wrongful death claim requires a strong presentation of both.

The Calculation Method for Economic Damages

Calculating economic damages is a meticulous, evidence-based process. The goal is to produce a concrete number that accurately reflects the family’s total financial loss.

Gather Documentation: The first step is to collect all relevant financial records. This includes years of tax returns, pay stubs, employment contracts, bank statements, medical bills, and funeral receipts.
Hire Expert Witnesses: Wrongful death attorneys work with a team of experts to analyze this data. A forensic accountant can verify past income and expenses. A vocational expert can testify about the decedent’s career path and promotion potential. A forensic economist takes all this information and builds a complex financial model to project future losses.
Project Future Losses: The economist will project the decedent’s lost earnings over their expected work-life, factoring in inflation, potential raises, and lost benefits. They will also calculate the value of lost household services.
Discount to Present Value: Because the family receives the award as a lump sum, the total future loss is “discounted” to its present value. This calculation determines the amount of money that, if invested prudently today, would generate an income stream to cover the projected future losses.

The Subjective Valuation of Non-Economic Damages

There is no calculator or spreadsheet for human grief. The valuation of non-economic damages is inherently subjective and is one of the most challenging aspects of a wrongful death case. The final decision rests with the jury, who must listen to the evidence and decide on a monetary figure that they believe is fair and just.

While there is no set formula, attorneys and juries may be influenced by certain concepts:

The Multiplier Method: In some personal injury cases, non-economic damages are estimated by multiplying the total economic damages by a number, typically between 1.5 and 5. The multiplier depends on the severity of the loss. While not a formal rule in wrongful death cases, this concept can provide a rough frame of reference.
The Per Diem Method: This approach involves assigning a dollar amount for each day the family will have to live with their loss. The attorney might ask the jury to consider what amount would be fair compensation for a single day of grief and then multiply that by the number of days in the family members’ expected lifetimes.

Ultimately, these are just conceptual tools. The jury’s decision will be based on the power and credibility of the evidence presented.

The Importance of Evidence and Testimony

The strength of a wrongful death claim hinges on the quality of the evidence. For economic damages, the evidence is documentary: bills, receipts, and expert reports. For non-economic damages, the evidence is human. Attorneys build this part of the case by:

Presenting Testimony: Family members, friends, coworkers, and neighbors will be asked to testify about the decedent’s character, their relationship with the family, and the profound impact their death has had.
Using Visuals: Photographs and home videos can be incredibly powerful tools to show the jury the person who was lost, not just the numbers on a page. They illustrate the loving relationships and the vibrant life that was cut short.
Submitting Personal Documents: Journals, letters, and emails can provide a window into the family’s life and the depth of their bonds.

State Laws and Caps on Wrongful Death Damages

The legal framework for wrongful death claims is determined at the state level, which means the rights of surviving family members can differ dramatically depending on where the death occurred. These variations affect who can sue, what types of damages are available, and whether there are limits on the amount of compensation that can be awarded.

The Variation Between States

There is no federal wrongful death law. Every state has its own set of statutes. For example, some states have historically been more restrictive, allowing families to recover only for “pecuniary” or economic losses. However, the majority of states now permit the recovery of both economic and non-economic damages, recognizing that the human loss is just as significant as the financial one. The specific definitions of what constitutes non-economic loss, such as “grief” versus “mental anguish,” can also differ.

Understanding Damage Caps

One of the most contentious issues in civil justice is the use of damage caps. A damage cap is a law that places a limit on the amount of non-economic damages a jury can award in certain types of cases. These caps are most common in medical malpractice lawsuits but can apply to other wrongful death claims as well.

Proponents’ Argument: Supporters of damage caps, often insurance companies and medical associations, argue that they are necessary to control litigation costs, reduce insurance premiums, and prevent “runaway” jury verdicts.
Opponents’ Argument: Critics, including victim advocacy groups and many trial lawyers, contend that caps are arbitrary and unfair. They argue that a cap disproportionately harms those who have suffered the most, such as the family of a child who has died. Since a child has no income, the bulk of the family’s claim is for non-economic damages, which would be severely limited by a cap.

The existence and amount of these caps vary widely. Some states have no caps at all, while others have limits ranging from $250,000 to over a million dollars.

Who is Eligible to Recover Damages?

State law also strictly defines who has the legal standing to file a wrongful death lawsuit and receive compensation. The eligible parties typically follow a clear hierarchy:

Surviving Spouse and Minor Children: They are almost always the primary beneficiaries.
Adult Children: Most states allow adult children to recover damages.
Parents of the Deceased: Parents can often file a claim, especially if the deceased was a minor or provided them with financial support.
Other Relatives or Dependents: In some circumstances, siblings, grandparents, or anyone who was financially dependent on the deceased may be able to file a claim.

An attorney can clarify who is eligible to file a claim under the specific laws of the relevant state.

The Role of Punitive Damages in Wrongful Death Cases

In addition to economic and non-economic damages, which are known as compensatory damages, a third category may sometimes be available: punitive damages. These are fundamentally different in their purpose and are awarded only in rare circumstances.

What Are Punitive Damages?

Punitive damages are not designed to compensate the family for their loss. Instead, their purpose is to punish the defendant for particularly reprehensible behavior and to deter that defendant and others from engaging in similar conduct in the future. They serve as a public condemnation of the defendant’s actions, sending a message that such behavior will not be tolerated.

When Are Punitive Damages Awarded?

An award of punitive damages is reserved for cases that go beyond simple negligence. The plaintiff must prove that the defendant acted with malice, fraud, or a conscious and reckless disregard for the safety and lives of others. The standard of proof is also higher, typically requiring “clear and convincing evidence” rather than the “preponderance of the evidence” standard used for compensatory damages.

Examples of situations that might warrant punitive damages include:

A drunk driver with a long history of DUI convictions causes a fatal crash.
A corporation knowingly markets a product with a dangerous defect that it concealed from the public.
A nursing home is found to have a pattern of egregious neglect and abuse that led to a resident’s death.

Legal Standards and Limits on Punitive Awards

Because punitive damages are meant to punish, there are legal and constitutional limits on their size. The U.S. Supreme Court has ruled that excessively large punitive damage awards can violate the Due Process Clause of the Constitution. Courts often look at the ratio between the punitive award and the compensatory award, suggesting that a single-digit ratio (e.g., 9 to 1 or less) is more likely to be upheld. Furthermore, many states have passed laws that place specific caps on punitive damages, and some states prohibit them entirely in wrongful death cases.

Practical Steps for Families Pursuing a Wrongful Death Claim

For a family grieving a sudden loss, the prospect of a legal case can feel like an added burden. However, taking certain steps early on can protect their legal rights and strengthen their ability to secure fair compensation for their loss.

Preserving Evidence and Documenting Losses

The foundation of any successful claim is strong evidence. Families should begin gathering and preserving important documents as soon as they are able.

Financial Records: Collect all possible financial documents, including several years of the decedent’s tax returns, pay stubs, W-2s, and information about their retirement plans and benefits.
Medical and Funeral Bills: Keep a file of every bill related to the final medical care and all receipts from the funeral and burial.
Personal Mementos: Gather photos, home videos, letters, and anything else that illustrates the close relationship the family shared with the deceased. This evidence is vital for proving non-economic damages.
Journaling: It can be helpful for family members to write down their feelings and document how the loss is affecting their daily lives. This can serve as a personal record of their mental and emotional anguish.

Understanding the Statute of Limitations

Every state has a law called the statute of limitations, which sets a strict deadline for filing a wrongful death lawsuit. This time limit usually begins on the date of the person’s death. The period varies by state but is typically between one and three years. If a lawsuit is not filed before this deadline expires, the family loses its right to seek compensation forever. This makes it critically important to speak with an attorney as soon as possible.

Why Consulting with a Wrongful Death Attorney is Critical

Wrongful death law is a specialized and complex field. An experienced attorney provides invaluable guidance and advocacy for a grieving family. Their role includes:

Investigating the Death: Conducting a thorough investigation to determine all potentially liable parties.
Hiring Experts: Retaining the necessary forensic economists, medical experts, and accident reconstructionists to build a strong case.
Calculating Full Damages: Working with experts to ensure that both economic and non-economic losses are fully calculated and justified.
Handling Communications: Managing all communication and negotiations with insurance companies and defense lawyers.
Litigating the Case: Filing the lawsuit and representing the family in court if a fair settlement cannot be reached.

Most wrongful death lawyers work on a contingency fee basis. This means the family pays no upfront fees, and the attorney’s fee is a percentage of the compensation they recover. This arrangement allows any family to access high-quality legal representation, regardless of their financial situation.

Need help claiming what’s fair? Contact Life Justice Law Group today.

Conclusion

The distinction between economic and non-economic damages is at the heart of every wrongful death claim. Economic damages address the tangible, financial void created by a loved one’s death, providing the resources necessary for a family to maintain its stability. They are calculated based on hard data, from lost wages to medical bills. Non-economic damages, in contrast, seek to acknowledge the irreplaceable human loss, the grief, the absence of companionship, and the loss of parental guidance. They recognize that the true cost of a life cannot be found on a balance sheet.

For a family to achieve a just outcome, both categories of damages must be fully and persuasively presented. A comprehensive claim honors the whole person who was lost, accounting for both their financial contributions and the love, support, and joy they brought to their family. The legal process is intricate, and the laws governing these claims vary from one state to another, creating different challenges and opportunities for recovery.

The loss of a family member due to someone else’s negligence is a deeply personal and painful experience. Pursuing legal action is not about putting a price on a life. It is about holding the responsible parties accountable for their actions and securing the financial future of those left behind. Because strict deadlines apply to these cases, it is essential to act promptly. If your family is in this difficult position, speaking with a qualified wrongful death attorney is the most important step you can take to protect your rights and understand the path toward justice. Contact us for free evaluation today, and let us fight for the justice your family deserves.

Economic vs. Non-Economic Damages: Understanding Compensation in a Wrongful Death Claim