Wrongful Death Caused by a Criminal Act

TL;DR

If a loved one’s death was caused by a criminal act, the surviving family members can file a civil lawsuit for wrongful death, completely separate from any criminal charges. This civil claim seeks monetary damages to compensate the family for their financial and emotional losses. The key difference is the burden of proof; the civil case only requires showing it was “more likely than not” that the defendant was responsible, a much lower standard than the “beyond a reasonable doubt” needed for a criminal conviction. This means a family can win a wrongful death lawsuit even if the defendant is found not guilty in criminal court.

Key Highlights

Two Separate Cases: A criminal prosecution seeks to punish the offender, while a civil wrongful death lawsuit seeks financial compensation for the victim’s family.
Different Burdens of Proof: Criminal cases require proof “beyond a reasonable doubt.” Civil cases only require a “preponderance of the evidence.”
You Can Still Sue: A not-guilty verdict in a criminal trial does not prevent you from filing and winning a civil lawsuit for the same act.
Who Can File: Laws specify which family members (like a spouse, children, or parents) or the deceased’s estate representative can bring the claim.
Types of Compensation: Damages can cover lost income, funeral expenses, loss of companionship, and in some cases, punitive damages to punish the defendant.

When a person’s life is cut short by a criminal act, the focus of the justice system often turns to the prosecution of the offender. According to FBI data, thousands of homicides occur each year, and for each one, a criminal case may be pursued by the state. This process involves police investigations, prosecutors, and the potential for punishments like prison time. This is the side of justice most people see on the news, the state holding an individual accountable for breaking the law.

However, the criminal justice system is designed to address the wrong done to society, not the personal losses suffered by the victim’s family. While a conviction may bring a sense of public justice, it does little to address the profound financial and emotional voids left behind. This is where a different part of the legal system comes into play: civil law. Under tort law, when one person’s wrongful actions cause harm to another, the injured party has the right to seek compensation. In the case of a fatality, this right extends to the surviving family members through a wrongful death claim.

The existence of this parallel legal path is a critical resource for families grappling with loss from a criminal act. It provides a mechanism for them to seek direct accountability from the person responsible for their loved one’s death. This civil action is not dependent on the success, or even the existence, of a criminal prosecution. It empowers families to pursue justice on their own terms, focusing on the financial stability and acknowledgment of their immense personal suffering.

Hold them accountable. Talk to Life Justice Law Group now.

Understanding the Two Parallel Justice Systems: Civil vs. Criminal

When a death results from a criminal act, two distinct legal processes can unfold simultaneously. These are the criminal prosecution and the civil wrongful death lawsuit. While they both stem from the same tragic event, they operate in different courts, have different goals, and follow different rules. Understanding this distinction is the first step for any family considering their legal options.

The Goal of a Criminal Prosecution

A criminal case is an action brought by the government (the state or federal government) against an individual who has allegedly broken the law. The primary objective is to punish the offender and protect society.

Who is Involved: The parties are the “prosecution” (representing the government, led by a prosecutor or district attorney) and the “defendant” (the person accused of the crime). The victim’s family are witnesses, but they are not a party to the case and do not control the prosecutor’s decisions.
The Purpose: The goal is to determine guilt and impose a penalty. This punishment can include imprisonment, fines paid to the state, probation, or other sanctions. The focus is on retribution and deterrence, not on compensating the victim’s family.
The Outcome: If the defendant is found guilty, they are sentenced by a judge. If they are found not guilty (acquitted), they are free from criminal punishment for that specific charge.

The Purpose of a Wrongful Death Lawsuit

A wrongful death lawsuit is a civil action, not a criminal one. It is a private lawsuit filed by the deceased person’s family members or estate against the person or entity responsible for the death.

Who is Involved: The parties are the “plaintiff” (the family members or estate representative) and the “defendant” (the person who caused the death). The family and their attorney control the lawsuit.
The Purpose: The goal is not to send anyone to jail. Instead, the objective is to hold the defendant financially responsible for the harm they caused. The lawsuit seeks monetary damages to cover the losses the family has suffered because of their loved one’s death.
The Outcome: If the plaintiff wins, the defendant is found “liable” (responsible) and is ordered by the court to pay a specific amount of money to the family. There is no possibility of a prison sentence resulting from a civil lawsuit.

Key Differences in a Nutshell

Feature	Criminal Case	Civil Wrongful Death Case
Purpose	To punish the offender and protect society.	To compensate the victim’s family for their losses.
Who Files	The government (prosecutor).	The victim’s family or estate representative.
Parties	State vs. Defendant.	Plaintiff vs. Defendant.
Burden of Proof	Beyond a Reasonable Doubt.	Preponderance of the Evidence.
Potential Outcome	Prison, fines, probation.	Monetary damages paid to the family.
Defendant’s Rights	Right to an attorney, right against self-incrimination.	Fewer constitutional protections.

The Critical Difference: Burden of Proof Explained

The single most important distinction between a criminal and civil case is the “burden of proof.” This legal standard determines how much evidence is needed to prove the case. The difference in these standards is why a person can be acquitted in criminal court but still be held financially liable in a civil court for the very same act.

“Beyond a Reasonable Doubt” in Criminal Cases

In the American criminal justice system, a defendant is presumed innocent until proven guilty. To overcome this presumption, the prosecutor must present evidence that is so convincing there is no other logical explanation that can be derived from the facts except that the defendant committed the crime. This is the highest burden of proof in the legal system.

If a jury has any “reasonable doubt” about the defendant’s guilt, they must vote to acquit. This high bar is designed to protect citizens from being wrongfully convicted and deprived of their liberty. However, it also means that if there is a missing piece of evidence or a plausible alternative theory, a guilty person might go free.

“Preponderance of the Evidence” in Civil Cases

A civil wrongful death lawsuit operates under a much lower and more straightforward standard: “preponderance of the evidence.” To win, the plaintiff’s attorney must convince the jury that it is more likely than not that the defendant is responsible for the death.

Think of it like a scale. If the plaintiff’s evidence weighs the scale down even slightly in their favor, 50.1% versus 49.9%, they have met their burden of proof. The jury does not need to be 100% certain. They only need to believe that the plaintiff’s version of events is more probable than the defendant’s. This makes it significantly easier to prove liability in a civil case than to prove guilt in a criminal one.

The O.J. Simpson Case: A Real-World Example

The most famous illustration of this principle is the case of O.J. Simpson. In 1995, he was tried for the murders of Nicole Brown Simpson and Ron Goldman.

The Criminal Trial: The prosecution presented a mountain of evidence, but the defense team was able to create doubt in the minds of the jurors. They questioned the integrity of the evidence collection and offered alternative theories. Because the jury had a reasonable doubt, they acquitted Simpson of the murder charges. He faced no jail time.
The Civil Trial: Following the acquittal, the families of Ron Goldman and Nicole Brown filed a wrongful death lawsuit against Simpson. In this civil trial, the same evidence was presented. However, the families’ attorneys only had to prove it was “more likely than not” that Simpson was responsible for the deaths. The civil jury found him liable and ordered him to pay $33.5 million in damages to the families.

This outcome was not a contradiction. It was a direct result of the two different burdens of proof. The criminal jury was not sure enough to convict beyond a reasonable doubt, but the civil jury found that the evidence made it more probable than not that he was responsible.

Who Has the Right to File a Wrongful Death Claim?

Not just anyone can file a wrongful death lawsuit after a loved one passes away. Each state has specific laws, known as statutes, that define who is eligible to bring such a claim. These laws are meant to ensure that the compensation goes to the people most affected by the loss. While the rules vary, they generally follow a similar pattern.

Identifying the Eligible Parties

State laws create a hierarchy of relatives who can file. The primary beneficiaries are almost always the closest family members.

Surviving Spouse: In nearly every state, the surviving husband or wife is the first in line to file a wrongful death claim.
Children: The deceased person’s children (both minor and adult) are also typically primary beneficiaries. If a child is a minor, a legal guardian may need to file the lawsuit on their behalf.
Parents: If the deceased was unmarried and had no children, their surviving parents usually have the right to file the claim.
Other Relatives: In some situations, more distant relatives like siblings or grandparents might be able to file, but this is less common and often depends on whether they were financially dependent on the deceased.

It is crucial to understand that these rules are strict. If you do not fall into one of the categories defined by your state’s statute, you may not be able to file a lawsuit, even if you had a close relationship with the person who died.

The Role of the Personal Representative or Executor

Some states take a different approach. Instead of allowing family members to file directly, they require the “personal representative” of the deceased person’s estate to file the lawsuit.

Who is the Personal Representative? This person is often named in the deceased’s will (as an “executor”) or is appointed by the court if there is no will (as an “administrator”). This individual could be a family member, a friend, or a professional.
Filing on Behalf of Beneficiaries: The personal representative files the lawsuit on behalf of the estate and all the eligible beneficiaries. Any money recovered from the lawsuit is then distributed to the surviving family members according to the state’s inheritance laws or the terms of the will.

This process centralizes the legal action, preventing multiple lawsuits from different family members. The representative acts as the legal voice for the deceased and their heirs.

State-Specific Variations to Consider

The laws governing who can file a wrongful death claim can be complex and differ significantly from one state to another. For example, some states may allow a “life partner” or “putative spouse” to file, while others strictly limit claims to legally married spouses. The best course of action is to consult with an attorney who is familiar with the specific wrongful death statutes in the state where the death occurred. They can provide a clear determination of who has the legal standing to pursue a claim.

Types of Damages You Can Recover in a Civil Lawsuit

The purpose of a wrongful death lawsuit is to secure financial compensation, known as “damages,” for the family’s losses. These damages are intended to provide financial stability and acknowledge the profound personal impact of the death. Courts typically divide damages into three main categories: economic, non-economic, and punitive.

Economic Damages: Calculating Financial Losses

Economic damages are tangible, calculable financial losses that the family has incurred and will incur due to their loved one’s death. The goal is to restore the family to the financial position they would have been in had the death not occurred.

Lost Income and Future Earning Capacity: This is often the largest component of economic damages. It includes the wages, salary, and benefits the deceased would have earned over the remainder of their working life. An economist may be hired to project these future earnings based on the person’s age, profession, education, and career trajectory.
Loss of Services: This compensates for the value of the services the deceased provided to the household, such as childcare, home maintenance, cooking, and financial management.
Medical Expenses: The family can recover any medical bills that were incurred for the treatment of the deceased’s injuries between the time of the criminal act and their death.
Funeral and Burial Costs: The reasonable costs associated with the funeral, burial, or cremation are recoverable.

Non-Economic Damages: The Human Cost of the Loss

Non-economic damages are meant to compensate for the intangible, emotional, and personal losses that have no exact price tag. These damages acknowledge the human suffering caused by the death.

Loss of Companionship, Society, and Consortium: This is compensation for the loss of the love, affection, comfort, and companionship the deceased provided. For a spouse, this is often called “loss of consortium.”
Pain and Suffering of the Survivors: This addresses the mental anguish, grief, and emotional distress experienced by the surviving family members.
Loss of Guidance and Nurturing: If the deceased had minor children, damages can be awarded for the loss of the guidance, training, and nurturing they would have provided.
The Deceased’s Pain and Suffering: In some cases, if the deceased was conscious and suffered between the time of the injury and their death, the estate can recover damages for that suffering. This is often part of a “survival action” filed alongside the wrongful death claim.

Punitive Damages: Punishing the Wrongdoer

Unlike economic and non-economic damages, which are compensatory, punitive damages are intended to punish the defendant and deter similar conduct in the future. They are not awarded in every case. Punitive damages are typically reserved for situations where the defendant’s conduct was particularly malicious, reckless, or intentional, qualities often present in a wrongful death caused by a criminal act.

For example, if the death was caused by a drunk driver with multiple prior DUIs or was the result of a violent assault, a jury might award punitive damages to send a strong message that such behavior will not be tolerated. There are often state-imposed caps on the amount of punitive damages that can be awarded.

How a Criminal Case Can Impact Your Civil Claim

While the civil and criminal cases are separate, they are not isolated from one another. The progress and outcome of the criminal prosecution can have a significant effect on your wrongful death lawsuit. In many instances, the work done by law enforcement and prosecutors can provide a powerful advantage in the civil arena.

Using a Criminal Conviction as Evidence

If the defendant is convicted or pleads guilty in the criminal case, it can make your civil case much easier to win. This is due to a legal doctrine called “collateral estoppel” or “issue preclusion.”

This principle prevents a person from re-litigating an issue that has already been decided in another court case. Since a criminal conviction requires proving guilt “beyond a reasonable doubt,” that finding of guilt can be used to automatically establish the defendant’s liability in the civil case, which has a lower burden of proof. In other words, if the defendant was found guilty of manslaughter in criminal court, they cannot argue in civil court that they weren’t responsible for the death. This allows your attorney to focus solely on proving the extent of your family’s damages.

What Happens if There is an Acquittal or No Charges are Filed?

It is essential to remember that an acquittal in a criminal trial does not stop you from pursuing a civil claim. As demonstrated by the O.J. Simpson case, the lower “preponderance of the evidence” standard in civil court means you can still win. Your attorney will proceed with the civil case independently, building your case from the ground up.

Similarly, a prosecutor may decide not to file criminal charges for various reasons, such as insufficient evidence to meet the high criminal standard. This decision has no legal bearing on your right to file a civil lawsuit. The civil justice system provides an alternative avenue for accountability when the criminal system does not or cannot act.

Gathering Evidence: Parallel Investigations

The evidence collected during the criminal investigation is often invaluable for a wrongful death lawsuit. Your attorney can obtain and use a wide range of materials gathered by law enforcement, including:

Police reports and accident reconstruction reports.
Witness statements and interviews.
Photographs and video evidence from the scene.
Forensic evidence, such as DNA, ballistics, or toxicology reports.
The defendant’s testimony or statements made during the criminal proceedings.

In addition to this, your attorney will conduct their own investigation through the civil “discovery” process. This can involve taking depositions (sworn testimony) from the defendant and witnesses, requesting documents, and hiring experts to analyze the facts of the case. This dual-track investigation can often uncover more information than a criminal case alone.

The Practical Steps to Take and Critical Deadlines

When you are grieving the loss of a family member, taking legal action may be the last thing on your mind. However, there are time-sensitive steps and deadlines that must be met to protect your right to file a wrongful death claim. Acting promptly can make a significant difference in the outcome of your case.

The Statute of Limitations: A Deadline You Cannot Miss

Every state has a law called the “statute of limitations,” which sets a strict time limit for filing a lawsuit. For wrongful death claims, this period is typically between one and three years from the date of the person’s death.

What Happens if You Miss the Deadline? If you try to file a lawsuit after the statute of limitations has expired, the court will almost certainly dismiss your case, and you will permanently lose your right to seek compensation.
Exceptions Can Apply: In some limited circumstances, the clock might be “tolled” or paused. For example, if the person responsible for the death was not identified until later, the deadline might be extended. However, relying on these exceptions is risky.

Because this deadline is absolute, it is vital to speak with an attorney as soon as possible to ensure your claim is filed on time.

Preserving Evidence and Documenting Everything

While your legal team will handle the formal investigation, there are steps you can take to help preserve crucial information.

Keep All Documents: Gather and keep any documents related to your loved one and the incident, including their death certificate, medical bills, funeral expense receipts, and any correspondence from law enforcement or insurance companies.
Write Down What You Know: Make a list of everything you remember about the incident, including the names and contact information of any potential witnesses. Memories can fade, so writing things down early is helpful.
Avoid Speaking to the Other Party’s Insurer: If you are contacted by the defendant’s insurance company, do not give a recorded statement or sign any documents without first speaking to your own attorney. Their goal is to limit their financial liability, not to help you.

Why Consulting with a Wrongful Death Attorney is Essential

Cases involving a criminal act are legally complex and emotionally taxing. Trying to handle one on your own while grieving is a monumental task. An experienced wrongful death attorney can lift this burden from your shoulders.

An attorney will:

Evaluate your case and explain your legal rights.
Ensure all deadlines, like the statute of limitations, are met.
Investigate the claim and gather all necessary evidence.
Hire experts, such as economists and accident reconstructionists, to build a strong case.
Calculate the full value of your family’s damages.
Handle all communications with insurance companies and opposing counsel.
Represent you in settlement negotiations and, if necessary, in court.

Having a dedicated advocate on your side allows you to focus on your family’s healing while they focus on securing the financial accountability you deserve.

Seek justice after tragedy, contact Life Justice Law Group today.

A Path Toward Accountability

Losing a family member due to a criminal act creates a profound sense of loss and injustice. While the criminal justice system seeks to punish the wrongdoer on behalf of society, it often leaves families feeling like bystanders in a process that does not address their personal devastation. The civil justice system, however, offers a direct path for families to seek accountability for themselves. A wrongful death lawsuit empowers you to hold the responsible party financially liable for the full scope of your loss, from lost income and funeral bills to the irreplaceable loss of love and companionship.

The most critical takeaway is that a civil case is independent of any criminal proceedings. The lower burden of proof, “preponderance of the evidence” means that a successful wrongful death claim is possible even when a criminal prosecution fails or never begins. By understanding the differences between the two systems, who is eligible to file a claim, and the types of damages available, you can make informed decisions during a difficult time. The legal deadlines are strict, and the process is intricate, making prompt action essential.

If your family is in this tragic situation, the most important step you can take is to seek guidance from a legal professional who specializes in wrongful death cases. An experienced attorney can protect your rights, explain your options in clear terms, and manage the legal complexities on your behalf. Taking this step is not about retribution; it is about securing your family’s future and achieving a measure of justice for the loved one you have lost. Do not wait to get the answers and support you need to move forward. Contact us for free evaluation today, and let us fight for the justice your family deserves.