TL;DR
A structured settlement for a wrongful death claim is a financial arrangement where compensation is paid out over time through a series of periodic payments, rather than as a single lump sum. This method, established through a financial product called an annuity, provides long-term financial security for the surviving family members, ensuring a stable and predictable income stream to cover future needs like lost wages, education costs, and daily living expenses. Under Section 104(a)(2) of the Internal Revenue Code, these payments are generally received completely free from federal and state income taxes.
Key Highlights
- What It Is: A stream of scheduled, periodic payments from a wrongful death settlement instead of a one-time cash payment.
- How It Works: The defendant’s insurance company uses the settlement funds to purchase an annuity from a highly-rated life insurance company, which then makes the guaranteed payments to the beneficiaries.
- Primary Benefit: It provides long-term, stable, and predictable income, protecting the settlement funds from mismanagement and market volatility.
- Tax Advantage: Payments received from a structured settlement for a wrongful death claim are typically exempt from all federal and state income taxes.
- Customization: Payment schedules can be precisely tailored to meet specific future financial needs, such as funding a college education, paying off a mortgage, or supplementing retirement income.
Introduction
The loss of a family member creates a void that can never be filled. Beyond the emotional pain, families often face a sudden and severe financial crisis. According to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC), unintentional injuries are a leading cause of death in the United States, resulting in tens of thousands of wrongful death claims each year. These claims seek to provide financial compensation for the economic devastation that follows, including the loss of the deceased’s income, benefits, and support, which can destabilize a family’s future for generations.
When a wrongful death case is resolved, the responsible party’s insurer provides compensation to the surviving family members, known as beneficiaries. The legal framework, governed by state-specific wrongful death statutes, defines who can receive this compensation and what damages are recoverable. These damages often include quantifiable losses like medical bills, funeral costs, and the lifetime value of lost earnings. The process culminates in a settlement agreement, a legally binding contract that specifies the total compensation amount.
At this critical point, the family must make a decision with profound and lasting financial consequences: how to receive the settlement funds. The choice is typically between a single lump-sum payment or a structured settlement that provides a series of payments over time. This decision is not merely about preference; it is a strategic choice that directly impacts the family’s long-term financial health, tax liability, and protection from future uncertainty. Understanding the mechanics, benefits, and drawbacks of a structured settlement is essential for making an informed choice that truly honors the goal of the compensation: to provide lasting security for the people left behind.
Find the right settlement plan for your family with Life Justice Law Group.
Understanding the Mechanics of a Wrongful Death Structured Settlement
A structured settlement can seem complex, but its core concept is straightforward. Instead of handing the beneficiaries a check for the full settlement amount, the money is used to create a secure, long-term income plan. This is achieved through a specific legal and financial process designed for maximum security and tax efficiency.
What is a Structured Settlement? A Plain English Definition
Think of a structured settlement as a pre-planned financial roadmap. It is a voluntary agreement between the plaintiff (the family) and the defendant to resolve a legal claim by paying the compensation in a series of periodic payments. These payments are funded by an annuity, which is a contract with a life insurance company that guarantees to make payments on a specified schedule. This stands in sharp contrast to a lump-sum payment, where the entire settlement amount is paid at once, leaving the family responsible for managing, investing, and preserving the funds for the rest of their lives.
The Key Players Involved
Several parties work together to establish a structured settlement:
- The Plaintiff (Beneficiaries): The surviving family members entitled to the wrongful death compensation.
- The Defendant: The at-fault party and, more commonly, their insurance company, which is responsible for paying the settlement.
- The Structured Settlement Consultant: A licensed specialist who helps the plaintiff and their attorney design the payment schedule. They solicit quotes from various life insurance companies to find the best terms and highest payout. Their fee is paid by the defendant’s insurer, not out of the plaintiff’s settlement.
- The Life Insurance Company (Annuity Issuer): A highly-rated insurance company that receives the settlement funds and issues the annuity contract, guaranteeing the future payments.
- The Assignment Company: A third-party company that formally accepts the liability to make the future payments from the defendant’s insurer. This is a legal step known as a “qualified assignment” that releases the defendant from future obligation and solidifies the tax-free nature of the payments for the plaintiff.
How the Annuity is Funded and Secured
The process is designed for safety. The defendant’s insurer sends the settlement money directly to the chosen life insurance company. This life insurance company then issues the annuity policy. The security of these payments rests on the financial strength of the life insurer. For this reason, consultants only work with companies that have top ratings from independent agencies like A.M. Best (e.g., A++, A+) and Standard & Poor’s. Furthermore, these annuities are protected by State Guaranty Associations, which act as a safety net for policyholders in the unlikely event an insurer fails.
The Legal Foundation: IRC Section 104(a)(2)
The most powerful feature of a structured settlement is its tax treatment. The Internal Revenue Code (IRC) Section 104(a)(2) states that compensation received on account of personal physical injuries or physical sickness is not included in gross income. The IRS has consistently interpreted wrongful death as falling under this provision. This means that 100% of every payment received from a wrongful death structured settlement, including the growth or “interest” portion earned inside the annuity, is completely free from federal and state income tax. This tax-free status provides a significant advantage over investing a lump sum, where all investment gains would be subject to capital gains or income taxes.
The Advantages of Choosing a Structured Settlement
When a family is dealing with grief, making complex financial decisions can be difficult. A structured settlement offers a way to secure their financial future with a plan that is both reliable and tailored to their specific needs. Its benefits center on security, tax efficiency, and customization.
Unmatched Financial Security and Stability
Statistics show that a large percentage of individuals who receive a sudden financial windfall, whether from a lottery or a settlement, deplete the funds within a few years. A structured settlement removes this risk. By providing a steady, recurring stream of payments, it ensures that money is available to pay the mortgage, cover living expenses, and fund education for years or even decades to come. This financial discipline is built into the plan, protecting the family from poor investment choices, market downturns, or pressure from others seeking financial help. It effectively replaces the lost income of the deceased with a guaranteed paycheck.
Significant Tax-Free Benefits
The tax advantage cannot be overstated. Let’s consider an example. If a family receives a $1 million lump sum and invests it, any dividends, interest, or capital gains generated by that investment are taxable. If the investments generate a 5% return, or $50,000 in a year, a significant portion of that gain could be lost to taxes.
With a structured settlement, the entire payment, including the portion that represents growth on the principal, is received tax-free. A structured settlement that pays out a total of $1.5 million over 20 years means the family receives the full $1.5 million. There are no annual tax forms to file on this income and no money is lost to the IRS. This tax-free growth allows the settlement to provide a much larger total payout than the initial amount.
Customization to Meet Life’s Milestones
A structured settlement is not a one-size-fits-all product. It is highly flexible and can be designed to meet a family’s unique and evolving needs. The payment schedule is created during the settlement negotiation process.
- Immediate Needs: A portion can be paid upfront to cover funeral expenses, medical bills, and outstanding debts.
- Income Replacement: A monthly or annual payment can be set up for a specific period (e.g., 20 years) or for the lifetime of a surviving spouse to replace lost income.
- Education Funding: Lump-sum payments can be scheduled to coincide with when children will be starting college. For example, payments of $50,000 could be scheduled for August of each year when a child is 18, 19, 20, and 21.
- Major Life Events: Payments can be designed to pay off a mortgage in 10 years, provide a down payment for a new home, or supplement retirement savings in the future.
Protection from Creditors and Poor Financial Decisions
Once established, the funds in a structured settlement are generally protected from outside claims. In most states, creditors cannot seize future payments to satisfy debts. The funds are also shielded in bankruptcy or divorce proceedings. This “spendthrift protection” ensures the money is preserved for its intended purpose: the long-term care of the beneficiaries. It also provides a buffer against making impulsive or emotionally driven financial decisions during a period of grief.
Potential Downsides and Considerations
While structured settlements offer powerful benefits, they are not the right choice for every situation. The main trade-off is giving up liquidity and control in exchange for security and tax benefits. It is crucial to understand these limitations before making a final decision.
The Inflexibility of a Fixed Payment Schedule
The greatest strength of a structured settlement, its guaranteed payment schedule, is also its primary weakness. Once the settlement agreement is signed and the annuity is purchased, the payment schedule is locked in and cannot be changed. You cannot call the insurance company and ask for a larger payment or an advance because of an unexpected financial emergency, such as a major medical issue or a home repair. This lack of liquidity means families must carefully plan for their future needs and consider setting aside a portion of the settlement as a lump-sum emergency fund.
The Role of Inflation
A fixed payment of $3,000 per month may seem sufficient today, but its purchasing power will decrease over time due to inflation. Over a 20 or 30-year period, the value of that fixed payment can be significantly eroded. To counter this, a Cost-of-Living Adjustment (COLA) can be added to the annuity contract. A COLA will increase the payments each year by a predetermined percentage, typically 2% to 4%. While adding a COLA will reduce the amount of the initial payments, it ensures that the income stream keeps pace with rising costs over the long term.
Lower Potential Returns Compared to Market Investments
A structured settlement annuity is a conservative financial instrument. It is designed for safety and predictability, not for high growth. The rate of return is modest compared to what could potentially be earned by investing a lump sum in the stock market over a long period. A family with significant financial expertise and a high tolerance for risk might be able to generate greater wealth by managing the funds themselves. However, this potential for higher returns comes with the risk of significant losses. The structured settlement eliminates this market risk entirely.
The “Factoring” Industry: Cashing Out Your Settlement
Beneficiaries who find themselves in a financial bind may be tempted by companies that offer to buy their future settlement payments in exchange for a present-day lump sum. This process is called “factoring.” While legal, it comes at a very high cost. These companies purchase the payments at a steep discount, meaning the beneficiary receives far less than the future payments are actually worth. Selling payments requires court approval, and a judge must agree that the transaction is in the best interest of the seller. This option should be viewed as a last resort for dire emergencies, not as a feature of the settlement.
Who Benefits Most from a Wrongful Death Structured Settlement?
Certain situations and types of beneficiaries are particularly well-suited for the security and long-term management provided by a structured settlement. The structure serves as a protective financial tool, ensuring that the settlement funds achieve their intended purpose.
Cases Involving Minor Children
When a wrongful death settlement involves beneficiaries who are minors, courts are highly focused on protecting the child’s financial future. A structured settlement is often the preferred, and sometimes court-mandated, solution.
- Preservation of Funds: It prevents the funds from being spent by a guardian before the child reaches adulthood.
- Staggered Payouts: The payment schedule can be designed to support the child through their minority and then provide funds at key life stages. For example, a structure could provide monthly payments for living expenses until age 18, followed by four annual lump sums for college, and another lump sum at age 25 or 30 to help with a down payment on a house or starting a business.
- Financial Maturity: This approach avoids giving an 18-year-old access to a very large sum of money before they have the financial experience to manage it wisely.
Surviving Spouses with Long-Term Needs
For a surviving spouse who relied on the deceased’s income, a structured settlement can provide a seamless replacement. A lifetime annuity can guarantee a monthly “paycheck” for the rest of the spouse’s life, no matter how long they live. This removes the fear of outliving one’s assets, a major concern for those managing a lump sum for retirement. The payments can be designed to increase over time to account for inflation, ensuring the spouse can maintain their standard of living without the stress of managing a large investment portfolio.
Beneficiaries with Special Needs
If a beneficiary has a disability and relies on government benefits like Supplemental Security Income (SSI) or Medicaid, receiving a lump-sum settlement can be disastrous. These benefits are means-tested, and a large cash infusion would likely disqualify the individual from receiving them. A structured settlement can be designed to work in conjunction with a Special Needs Trust (SNT). The annuity payments are made directly to the trust, not the individual. The trustee can then use the funds to pay for supplemental needs not covered by government benefits, such as therapy, transportation, and education, thereby preserving the beneficiary’s eligibility for essential public assistance.
Individuals Lacking Financial Management Experience
Many people are not equipped to manage a sudden, large sum of money. The complexities of investing, tax planning, and budgeting can be difficult. For families without financial expertise, a structured settlement provides a professionally managed solution. It removes the burden of investment decisions and the risk of falling prey to bad advice or fraudulent schemes. The plan is set up once by experts, and the family simply receives the guaranteed, tax-free payments as scheduled, allowing them to focus on their personal recovery.
The Process of Establishing a Structured Settlement
Putting a structured settlement in place is a methodical process that happens during the final stages of the wrongful death claim. It must be made part of the settlement agreement before any documents are signed or money changes hands.
Step 1: The Settlement Negotiation
The decision to structure all or part of a settlement is made during negotiations with the defendant’s insurer. The plaintiff’s attorney will inform the defense that their client wishes to structure the settlement. This is a common request, and insurance companies are well-equipped to handle it. The total cost of the settlement to the defendant is the same whether they pay a lump sum or fund a structure.
Step 2: Working with a Structured Settlement Consultant
The plaintiff’s attorney will bring in a structured settlement consultant to act as the family’s guide. This expert will sit down with the family to conduct a detailed financial needs analysis. They will discuss current debts, monthly expenses, and long-term goals like college education and retirement. This consultant’s role is to translate the family’s future financial needs into a concrete payment plan.
Step 3: Designing the Payment Schedule
Based on the needs analysis, the consultant will design one or more proposed payment schedules. They will then take the cost of the settlement (the amount the defendant is paying) and request quotes from multiple, highly-rated life insurance companies. These quotes will show exactly what payment streams each life insurer can offer for that cost.
Example Case Study: The Miller family settles a wrongful death claim for $1.5 million. They work with a consultant to design a hybrid plan:
- Immediate Lump Sum: They take $250,000 immediately to pay off the mortgage and other debts.
- Structured Portion: The remaining $1.25 million is used to fund an annuity that provides:
- $4,000 per month for 20 years for the surviving spouse’s living expenses.
- Two lump-sum payments of $75,000 each for their child’s college education, scheduled for the years the child turns 18 and 20.
- A final lump sum of $100,000 for the spouse at age 65 to supplement retirement.
Step 4: Finalizing the Legal Documents
Once the family agrees on a payment plan and a life insurance company, several legal documents are prepared to finalize the arrangement:
- Settlement Agreement and Release: This is the core document that details all terms of the settlement, including the payment schedule and the life insurer chosen.
- Annuity Contract: The policy issued by the life insurance company that details its promise to make the payments.
- Qualified Assignment: The legal document through which the defendant’s insurer formally transfers the obligation to make the payments to a third-party assignment company (usually a subsidiary of the life insurer). This step is critical for securing the tax-free status of the payments.
If the beneficiaries are minors, the entire plan must be submitted to a court for approval to ensure it is in the child’s best interest.
Lump Sum vs. Structured Settlement: Making the Right Choice
The decision between a lump sum and a structured settlement is deeply personal and depends on a family’s financial situation, risk tolerance, and long-term goals. Often, the best solution is not an all-or-nothing choice but a combination of both.
A Side-by-Side Comparison
| Feature | Lump-Sum Settlement | Structured Settlement |
| Financial Security | Depends entirely on beneficiary’s management. Vulnerable to market risk and mismanagement. | Guaranteed, predictable payments. Insulated from market volatility and poor decisions. |
| Tax Implications | Initial settlement is tax-free. All future investment earnings are taxable. | 100% of every payment, including all growth, is completely tax-free. |
| Flexibility | Complete control and immediate access to all funds. High liquidity for emergencies or opportunities. | Highly inflexible. The payment schedule is permanent and cannot be changed once finalized. |
| Investment Control | Beneficiary has full control over how the money is invested, for better or worse. | No control. The funds are managed conservatively by the life insurance company. |
| Protection | Funds can be subject to claims from creditors, lawsuits, and divorce proceedings. | Payments are generally protected from creditors, bankruptcy, and other claimants. |
Questions to Ask Your Attorney and Financial Advisor
To make an informed decision, you must ask the right questions of your professional team:
- What is the total guaranteed payout of the structured settlement plan versus the initial settlement amount?
- Can we include a Cost-of-Living Adjustment (COLA) to protect against inflation, and how does that affect the initial payment amounts?
- What is the financial strength rating (e.g., A.M. Best, S&P) of the life insurance company proposed to issue the annuity?
- What happens to the payments if the beneficiary passes away before all payments are made? (Discuss the importance of a “guarantee period” and naming a contingent beneficiary).
- What are the advantages and disadvantages of a hybrid approach for our specific family needs?
The Hybrid Option: Getting the Best of Both Worlds
For many families, the most practical solution is a hybrid settlement. This involves taking a portion of the settlement as an immediate lump sum and placing the remainder in a structured settlement. The upfront cash can be used to establish a robust emergency fund, pay off high-interest debt, make a down payment on a home, or make other necessary large purchases. The structured portion can then be dedicated to long-term needs, such as providing a monthly income stream and funding future goals like education and retirement. This approach provides both immediate flexibility and long-term security.
Secure your family’s future, consult Life Justice Law Group today.
Conclusion
The resolution of a wrongful death claim marks the end of a difficult legal process, but it is the beginning of a new financial reality for the surviving family. The choice between a lump sum, a structured settlement, or a hybrid plan is one of the most critical financial decisions a family will ever make. A structured settlement offers a powerful tool for creating lasting financial stability, providing guaranteed, tax-free income that can replace lost earnings and secure a family’s future for decades. Its strengths lie in its unparalleled security, tax efficiency, and ability to be customized to meet specific life goals.
However, this security comes at the cost of flexibility and control. The decision requires a careful and honest assessment of your family’s financial discipline, long-term needs, and tolerance for risk. There is no single right answer, only the answer that is right for you. This is not a decision to be made in isolation. It is essential to have a thorough discussion with your personal injury attorney, a trusted financial advisor, and a qualified structured settlement consultant. Together, this team of professionals can help you analyze your options and design a comprehensive plan that honors your loved one by providing a secure and stable future for the people they cared about most.
The financial path you choose will shape your family’s life for years to come. Before you sign any final settlement agreement, ensure you have explored every option and have a clear plan in place. To understand how a structured settlement could be tailored to your unique circumstances, seek a no-obligation consultation with legal and financial experts who can provide the clarity needed to make this vital choice with confidence. Contact us for free evaluation today, and let us fight for the justice your family deserves.